The Ultimate Guide to Choosing Between Level-Funded vs Self-Funded Plans

When it comes to providing health benefits, businesses today face crucial decisions in selecting the right funding model. For many, the choice between level-funded vs self-funded plans is key. Both plans offer unique benefits that cater to different business needs and budgets, but understanding these differences is essential for making the best choice for your organization. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll cover the essential aspects of level-funded vs self-funded plans to help you make an informed decision that supports both your company and its employees.

Understanding Level-Funded vs Self-Funded Plans

To determine the right plan, it’s important to grasp the fundamentals of level-funded vs self-funded plans. Each offers advantages that appeal to various company types, but each also comes with distinct costs, risks, and benefits that need careful consideration.

What Are Level-Funded Plans?

Level-funded health plans have grown popular among small and medium-sized businesses for their predictable costs, while still offering some of the flexibility associated with self-funding. A level-funded plan combines features of both fully insured and self-funded structures. With level funding, companies pay a fixed monthly rate covering claims and administrative expenses, allowing for more predictable budgeting.

How Level-Funded Plans Work

In level-funded plans, a business pays a predetermined monthly amount that goes toward estimated claims costs and administrative fees. The insurer calculates this rate based on business size, health risks, and past claims. Here’s an added benefit: if the actual claims are lower than projected, the company may receive a refund or credit at year’s end. This refund potential is a major draw of level-funded plans and makes them a cost-saving choice for certain employers.

Benefits of Level-Funded Plans

• Predictable Monthly Costs: With level-funded plans, budgeting is easier as costs are consistent.
• Refund Potential: If claims are lower than expected, a portion of the premium is refunded, offering cost-efficiency.
• Access to Claims Data: Level-funded plans provide more transparency, allowing employers to analyze claims trends and adjust wellness initiatives.
• Stop-Loss Coverage: These plans include stop-loss insurance to protect against unexpectedly high claims.

Who Should Consider Level-Funded Plans?

Level-funded plans are generally a good fit for small to medium-sized businesses that prefer predictable costs without bearing the full financial responsibility of self-funding. Employers with younger, healthier workforces can particularly benefit from level-funded plans, as they’re likely to see a refund at the end of the year if claims are low.

For additional insights, check out the Medcore Brokerage guide on employee benefits enrollment for small businesses.

Self-Funded Plans: Key Features and Benefits

While reviewing level-funded vs self-funded plans, many businesses find that self-funded plans offer greater flexibility but come with more financial risk. Self-funded or self-insured plans require employers to directly pay employee healthcare claims as they occur, rather than paying a fixed monthly premium. This model allows companies complete control over their benefits but demands more resources to manage claims risk.

How Self-Funded Plans Work

In a self-funded model, businesses only pay for actual claims, rather than an estimated monthly premium. Employers typically set aside funds to cover these expenses, and many purchase stop-loss insurance to manage high-cost claims. Self-funded plans give companies the freedom to design benefits that best suit their workforce, making them a flexible solution for businesses that want tailored healthcare coverage.

Explore more about self-funding options on HealthCare.gov.

Advantages of Self-Funded Plans

• Cost Savings: Self-funded plans allow businesses to pay only for the claims incurred, which can lead to significant savings, especially with lower claims.
• Plan Customization: Self-funded plans offer the most flexibility, enabling companies to design custom benefits.
• Federal Regulation: Self-funded plans are regulated by federal law under ERISA, which means they’re not subject to certain state insurance mandates, potentially saving on costs.

Key Challenges of Self-Funded Plans

While highly customizable, self-funded plans also require companies to take on full claims risk, which can lead to unplanned costs if claims are high. Smaller companies may find self-funding a financial challenge if they lack the cash reserves to handle potential large claims.

Stop-Loss Insurance in Self-Funded Plans

Stop-loss insurance is a crucial feature for companies considering self-funding. It reimburses employers for high claims costs exceeding a set threshold, making self-funding more feasible. Stop-loss insurance typically comes in two forms:

• Specific Stop-Loss: Covers high-cost claims for an individual.
• Aggregate Stop-Loss: Covers total claims exceeding projected maximums for the whole group.

For more detailed guidance on ERISA and how it applies to self-funded plans, visit the U.S. Department of Labor’s page on ERISA regulations.

Who Should Consider Self-Funded Plans?

Self-funded plans are generally a fit for larger companies with strong cash reserves and a commitment to long-term employee benefits strategies. Self-funding may appeal to companies that want to retain more control over plan structure, handle claims data analysis in-house, and invest in wellness programs to manage costs.

Reasons Employers Choose Level-Funded vs Self-Funded Plans

When it comes to level-funded vs self-funded plans, employers often have specific financial and organizational goals that guide their choice. Below are the primary reasons companies might choose one over the other.

Why Employers Choose Level-Funded Plans

Level-funded plans are popular among smaller businesses due to the balance they offer between stability and savings. Employers may choose level-funded plans for these reasons:

• Budget Stability: Fixed monthly payments make financial planning simpler. With level-funded plans, businesses avoid the unpredictability of self-funding while still enjoying potential refunds if claims are lower than expected.
• Lower Financial Risk: Unlike self-funding, where employers take on full risk, level-funded plans include protections such as stop-loss coverage. This is particularly valuable for companies without large cash reserves who want some of the benefits of self-funding but cannot afford high financial exposure.
• Simplified Administration: Level-funded plans are typically administered by third-party administrators (TPAs), who manage the day-to-day tasks of claims and compliance. This allows companies without extensive HR support to offer tailored benefits with reduced administrative burden.

Why Employers Choose Self-Funded Plans

Employers who prioritize flexibility and have adequate financial reserves often favor self-funded plans. Here are some reasons companies opt for self-funding:

• Customizable Benefits: Self-funded plans allow full control over plan structure. Employers can cover specific treatments, therapies, or wellness programs that align with employee needs, providing a fully tailored healthcare experience.
• Cost Efficiency: Businesses pay only for claims incurred, allowing them to save in years with low claims. This efficiency is especially beneficial for companies with younger or healthier employees who are less likely to file costly claims.
• Control Over Plan Reserves: With self-funded plans, businesses retain any surplus, enabling them to reinvest these funds. This contrasts with fully insured or level-funded plans, where insurers typically keep any surplus or unused claims funds.

Level-Funded vs Self-Funded Plans: A Direct Comparison

To make an informed decision on level-funded vs self-funded plans, it’s useful to compare key features side by side:

Feature	Level-Funded Plans	Self-Funded Plans
Payment Structure	Fixed monthly payments	Pay-as-you-go claims payments
Financial Risk	Limited (with stop-loss insurance)	Higher, full claim responsibility
Refund Potential	Yes, if claims are below projections	No, but potential savings if claims are low
Customizability	Moderate customization options	Fully customizable
Compliance	Adheres to state laws	Federally regulated, exempt from most state laws
Ideal For	Small to medium businesses needing predictability	Larger companies comfortable with more risk and flexibility

Which Plan is Right for Your Business?

Determining the best choice between level-funded vs self-funded plans depends on factors like company size, budget flexibility, and employee demographics. In general:

• Level-funded plans are ideal for small to medium-sized businesses with a younger workforce seeking predictability and potential refunds.
• Self-funded plans suit larger companies with the financial means to manage high claims costs and a desire for maximum control over benefits.

Tips for Making the Right Decision

To help you make the best choice between level-funded vs self-funded plans, consider the following:

• Review Employee Health Trends: Analyzing your workforce’s health data can reveal expected claim costs and determine which plan offers the best financial fit.
• Consult a Benefits Broker: Brokers can provide expert guidance on options, costs, and compliance considerations, helping you choose a plan that aligns with your company’s financial and operational goals.
• Evaluate Financial Stability: Ensure your organization has adequate cash flow to handle unexpected claims costs, especially if considering self-funding.
• Engage Employees in Decision-Making: Gathering employee feedback on healthcare priorities can enhance plan satisfaction and potentially lower claims through preventive initiatives.

Conclusion

Choosing the right plan in the level-funded vs self-funded plans debate is a significant decision that influences financial health, employee satisfaction, and long-term stability. By understanding your organization’s specific needs, budget capacity, and employee health data, you can select a funding structure that aligns with your goals and provides the right balance of cost control and care flexibility.

---

FAQs

What is a level-funded health plan?
A level-funded health plan is a type of insurance where businesses pay a fixed monthly amount to cover estimated claims and administrative costs, with potential refunds if claims are lower than expected.

How does self-funding work for health insurance?
In self-funding, employers pay employee healthcare claims directly as they occur, rather than pre-paying premiums. This model provides cost flexibility but also bears higher financial risk.

Are level-funded plans good for small businesses?
Yes, level-funded plans are often ideal for small to medium businesses because they offer cost predictability and potential savings, without the full risk of traditional self-funding.

What is stop-loss insurance?
Stop-loss insurance protects self-funded employers by capping their out-of-pocket expenses for high-cost claims. It helps manage risk and makes self-funding feasible for many businesses.

Do self-funded plans offer refunds?
No, self-funded plans don’t offer refunds. However, they can lead to savings if actual claims are lower than expected, as employers only pay for incurred claims.

Which is better: level-funded vs self-funded plans?
It depends on company size, risk tolerance, and goals. Level-funded plans are suitable for smaller businesses wanting predictable costs, while self-funded plans offer flexibility for companies ready to manage their claims.